[Blog](/blog) Show links Resources [Blog](/blog) [Breaches](/breaches) [eBooks, reports, & more](/resources) [Events](/events) [News](/news) [Cybersecurity](/category/cybersecurity) Show links Categories [Attack Surface Management](/category/attack-surface-management) [Company News](/category/company-news) [Compliance and Regulations](/category/compliance-and-regulations) [Cybersecurity](/category/cybersecurity) [Data Breaches](/category/data-breaches) [DevOps](/category/devops) [Human Cyber Risk](/category/human-cyber-risk) [Risks and Vulnerabilities](/category/risks-and-vulnerabilities) [Third-Party Risk Management](/category/third-party-risk-management) [Vendor Risk Management](/category/vendor-risk-management) [Carbon Black vs Symantec Endpoint Protection](/blog/carbon-black-vs-symantec-endpoint-protection) Publish date November 27, 2025 {x} minute read # Carbon Black vs Symantec Endpoint Protection [Get a demo](/contact-sales) [Free trial](/demo) [Download the PDF guide](#) [Free trial](/demo) Written by [Kaushik Sen](/team/kaushik-sen) Chief Marketing Officer Kaushik has a background in software engineering, enterprise solution architecture, and data analytics. He brings a unique, data-driven perspective to cybersecurity education. Reviewed by [Abi Tyas Tunggal](/team/abi-tyas-tunggal) Writer and Senior Product Manager at UpGuard. Abi's work has influenced leaders across cybersecurity, technology, and financial services. Table of contents Free resource ### [Download now](#) The [information security](/blog/information-security) (infosec) space is for the most part divided into two camps:  established players using a combination of old/new tactics for combating cybercrime, and market entrants attempting to rethink security from the ground up. Attack methods are increasingly sophisticated and require novel approaches for detection and remediation—since very little is understood about the next generation of threats, opportunities abound for both incumbent leaders and upstarts alike. And with targeted attacks and [advanced persistent threats (APT)](https://www.upguard.com/blog/what-is-an-advanced-persistent-threat) on the rise, newer players with innovative approaches to security are seeing ample opportunities for supplanting longstanding market leaders and their aging security products. One such upstart—Carbon Black—takes a different approach to security that utilizes signature-less threat prevention and application whitelisting. Let’s take a look at how the platform compares with security veteran [Symantec’s](/blog/tenable-vs-symantec-for-continuous-security) Endpoint Protection offering. ## Bit9 + Carbon Black Though founded back in 2002, Bit9 came into its own in 2014 with the acquisition of Carbon Black. Bit9’s agent-based platform architecture allows the enforcement of whitelist policies on every endpoint, while Carbon Black enables endpoint file behavior monitoring and real-time threat detection through endpoint-installed sensors and data recorders. The merging of the two effectively combines Bit9’s signature-less, whitelist-based threat protection with Carbon Black’s continuous monitoring and [incident response](/blog/incident-response-plan) capabilities. In 2016, the company was rebranded to Carbon Black. Carbon Black’s trust-based security model revolves heavily around its central whitelist database: a registry of trusted, known good software and their classifications/ratings. These trust ratings are provided by the Carbon Black Software Reputation Service—reputedly the world’s largest hash database of software. Additionally, the platform is augmented by the firm’s Threat Intelligence Cloud—a repository containing extended attributes for billions of software executables, as well as threat and trust ratings for published and rogue software. A distinction should be made between traditional security methods employed by standard IDS/IDPS solutions and whitelisting—the latter of which is employed by Carbon Black. Though both methods use file hashes to track file changes, whitelisting by default assumes a “deny” posture, as opposed to the default “allow” approach used by most IDS/IDPS offerings. In Carbon Black’s case, an application whitelist contains a list of known good applications and their file privileges. Because only trusted software is allowed to execute in one’s IT environment, malicious packages are prevented from making any unauthorized changes . This is especially crucial when dealing with [zero-day attacks](/blog/zero-day) that use [malware](/blog/malware) unknown or unidentifiable by traditional security tools. With Carbon Black, maliciously altered files can be easily be prevented from execution by checking the application whitelist. ## Symantec Endpoint Protection A recognized name in IT security, Symantec features a full line of solutions for securing and managing information, identities, and infrastructures. Its own answer to endpoint detection is called—appropriately enough—Symantec Endpoint Protection. The platform enables comprehensive infrastructure protection through the following core components: * **Endpoint Protection Manager—**a server that manages computers connected to a protected network. * **Endpoint Protection Manager Database—**a datastore of security policies and events * **Endpoint Protection Client—**endpoint software that protects and scans machines for viruses and malware. A firewall and IDPS are included with the suite, with paid add-ons available for extending Symantec Endpoint Protection’s capabilities. For example, purchasing the Symantec Protection Suite gives the platform the ability to filter/block email and web threats. Similar to Carbon Black, Symantec Endpoint Protection utilizes a trusted datastore for identifying files to  be scanned—in this case, with data provided by the Symantec Global Intelligence Network (GIN). This network of hundreds of millions of sensors feed data into a massive repository of security data gleaned from the monitoring, analyzing, and processing of more than 10 trillion security events per year worldwide. According to Symantec, this gives its platform significant speed benefits by incorporating scan elimination—instead of scanning every file, it eliminates and deduplicates unnecessary scan jobs for smarter and faster operation. ## Security Ratings UpGuard's [Vendor Risk Management tool](https://www.upguard.com/product/vendor-risk) is used by hundreds of companies to automatically monitor their third-party vendors. We ran a quick surface scan on both Carbon Black and Symantec, and found them to have similar scores: * [Carbon Black - 656 / 950](/instant-security-score/report?c=www.carbonblack.com) * [Symantec - 874 / 950](/instant-security-score/report?c=www.symantec.com) Our quick assessment showed that both companies carry similar risks which include: * Increased susceptibility to [man-in-the-middle attacks](/blog/man-in-the-middle-attack) through incomplete support for [HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS)](/blog/hsts). Although, Symantec is in a weaker position here as they do not even enforce HSTS. * Exposure of their web server details, such as name and version numbers. These can be run against [CVE (Common Vulnerability and Exposure)](/blog/cve) lists by attackers looking for weaknesses. * DNS being susceptible to man-in-the-middle attacks, as neither enforces [DNS Security Extensions (DNSSEC)](/blog/dnssec) on their domain. * Potential for emails to be fraudulently sent from their domain by spammers, as neither company enforces [Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting and Conformance (DMARC)](/blog/dmarc). Based on their score, Carbon Black edged out Symantec. But both companies have work to do in maintaining good security hygiene and best practices for themselves. **Let us automatically measure and monitor the security of Carbon Black, Symantec and your other third-party vendors for you.** [**Get a demo of UpGuard Vendor Risk today**](/demo)**.**  ## Summary [Cyber threats](https://www.upguard.com/blog/cyber-threat) are constantly evolving and security tools must follow suit. This cat-and-mouse game often puts many legacy vendors at a disadvantage, as they often lack the agility to reinvent ageing security models and architectures from the ground up. That said, newer security firms developing advanced methodologies for threat protection are essentially building solutions that are unproven against future threats. Symantec Endpoint Protection and Carbon Black are representative cases of each—interestingly enough, both incorporate consolidated [threat intelligence](https://www.upguard.com/blog/threat-intelligence) datastores as critical components of their respective offering. And despite the apparent similarities, Symantec’s GIN is actually quite different than Carbon Black’s whitelisting mechanism. The latter uses a hash database of software trust ratings— the Carbon Black Software Reputation Service—to determine which files to whitelist. The GIN datastore is used for quick identification of good and bad actors to optimize file scanning efficiency. Both approaches have their advantages and drawbacks. Symantec Endpoint Protection is comprehensive but lacks integration capabilities with other security tools like an SIEM. And no matter how expansive GIN’s intelligence gathering capabilities, the solution still relies on known threat data to drive its security enforcement model. Also, non-Windows users may be out of luck with Symantec, as the Manager component requires a Windows machine to run on. Carbon Black’s whitelisting technology seems promising, but needs further refinement—a [recent compromise](https://krebsonsecurity.com/2013/02/security-firm-bit9-hacked-used-to-spread-malware/) resulted in malware being sent to several of the company’s customers. And just to be fair, Symantec's offering has not been without [its own vulnerabilities.](https://www.offensive-security.com/vulndev/symantec-endpoint-protection-0day/) Suffice to say, no one solution can effectively protect an organization’s infrastructure against today and tomorrow’s threats. A competent security strategy should consist of best-of-breed tools assembled in a continuous security toolchain, with monitoring layered across them —through deep coverage, organizations can maintain an optimal [security posture](/blog/security-posture). | | | | | ----------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | |   | Carbon Black | Symantec Endpoint Protection | | installation and setup | Single endpoint installation is straightforwardSupports WIndows, MacOS, Red Hat Linux, and CentOSEnterprise environment require professional services, which can be costly | Installs as a standard Windows applicationManager component only works on Windows platforms | | Features | Built entirely on open APIs and features easy integration with other toolsUses the Carbon Black Software Reputation Service— the world’s largest hash database of software | Powered by the Symantec Global Intelligence Network (GIN), a big data repository of threat intelligence accumulated from one of the largest collection of sensors in the industryIncludes a standard suite of security tools including IDPS, firewall, and anti-virus/malware. | | Pricing | $420/3-year license | $54/1-year license | | Documentation & Support | Available on website | Available on website. Community support is fairly extensive | Free resource ### [Download now](#) ## Related posts Learn more about the latest issues in cybersecurity. Cybersecurity #### [12 Cybersecurity Horror Stories of 2026 (No Costume Required)](/blog/cybersecurity-horror-stories-2026) A warning ignored once becomes a headline. Read more about these 12 real 2026 cybersecurity incidents, and the sign each one gave before it made the news. [](/team/revashni-moodley) [Revashni Moodley](#) September 29, 2026 Cybersecurity #### [Left Unsupervised: 10 Times Access Outlived Its Authorization](/blog/10-times-access-outlived-authorization) Access granted once shouldn’t mean access forever. Read more on how unmonitored access caused 10 of these real-life breaches and what they taught us. [](/team/revashni-moodley) [Revashni Moodley](#) August 25, 2026 Cybersecurity #### [Surviving a LockBit Ransomware Attack: The ROI of Visibility](/blog/surviving-a-lockbit-ransomware-attack) Read how veteran CISO Nick Gicinto saved his alma mater from a LockBit ransomware attack by discarding the standard playbook. [](/team/nicholas-sollitto) [Nicholas Sollitto](#) June 1, 2026 Cybersecurity #### [Top 10 Security Events of 2025](/blog/top-security-events-of-2025) Recap the ten most impactful events that reshaped the cybersecurity industry this year and the critical lessons each had to teach us. Read more here. [](/team/revashni-moodley) [Revashni Moodley](#) January 7, 2026 Cybersecurity #### [Risk Automations: The Shift From Catch-Up to Command](/blog/risk-automations-shift-catch-up-to-command) Connect intelligence to system execution with Risk Automations, your new resolution layer for risk. Reduce remediation from hours to seconds - read more. [](/team/revashni-moodley) [Revashni Moodley](#) December 1, 2025 Cybersecurity #### [Shai-Hulud's True Lesson for CISOs: A Crisis of Communication](/blog/shai-hulud-lesson-for-cisos) Shai-Hulud was driven by a communication crisis between security and engineering. Get a CISO's perspective on how to finally bridge this gap. [](/team/phil-ross) [Phil Ross](#) September 3, 2026 [All posts](/blog) Experience superior visibility and a simpler approach to cyber risk management [Get a demo](/contact-sales) [Free trial](/demo)