Securing Your Supply Chain: Risk Management vs Security Management

Supply chain management has become a top priority for businesses due to the increasing use of digital technologies and geopolitical uncertainties, making global supply chains more vulnerable than ever to disruptions. This reality highlights two critical aspects of supply chain management: Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM) and Supply Chain Security Management (SCSM).

Private-sector businesses and public-facing entities who rely on supply chains to deliver products and services must understand the dynamics of SCRM and SCSM. Although these two functions are often seen as a single entity, they have distinct roles and approaches critical to protecting a business's operations against unforeseen challenges and threats. This blog will explore the differences and interconnections between SCRM and SCSM, providing insights into how organizations can strengthen their supply chains against various risks and security issues.

Enhance your organization’s supply chain management with UpGuard >

What is the Supply Chain?

The term "supply chain" refers to a complex network involving producing, handling, and distributing goods and services. This network starts from the initial raw materials and ends with the final delivery to the consumer. The process includes various stages: sourcing raw materials, manufacturing, warehousing, transportation, and distribution. Each stage of the supply chain involves different entities, including suppliers, manufacturers, distributors, retailers, and logistics providers.

The supply chain is not a simple linear process anymore. It has evolved into a dynamic and interconnected system across multiple countries and continents. This complex network involves a diverse group of suppliers and customers. Technology is pivotal in modern supply chains, providing tools for inventory management, demand forecasting, route optimization, and real-time communication among all parties. Due to this complexity and widespread network, managing supply chains has become increasingly challenging yet critical for business success in today's global economy.

Why is Supply Chain Management Important?

Supply chain management is not simply reducing costs or enhancing efficiency. Instead, it involves establishing a resilient, responsive, synchronized supply network that aligns with the business's strategic objectives.

In today's business environment, where consumer demands are constantly evolving, and market conditions are unpredictable, effective supply chain management is essential to achieving success and ensuring long-term viability. Other benefits of supply chain management include:

  1. Cost Efficiency: Effective supply chain management can lower costs and increase profitability at various stages by minimizing waste, storage costs, and operational expenses.
  2. Customer Satisfaction: A managed supply chain ensures prompt and efficient delivery, increasing customer satisfaction and loyalty in a competitive market.
  3. Increased Flexibility and Responsiveness: Supply chain management enables businesses to quickly adapt to changes in supply and demand, such as shifts in consumer preferences or disruptions in supply.
  4. Risk Mitigation: Cohesive management identifies and mitigates potential risks in the supply chain, ensuring continuity of operations and reducing disruptions.
  5. Competitive Advantage: An optimized supply chain can give businesses a competitive edge, allowing them to provide better service at a lower cost, outperform competitors, and capture more market share.

Supply Chain Risk Management Explained

Supply Chain Risk Management (SCRM) is a process that evaluates and mitigates risks within the supply chain to minimize their impact on business operations. It involves anticipating potential disruptions and developing strategies to handle them effectively. SCRM is a crucial risk management framework that maintains smooth operational flow and safeguards information systems and the business against significant financial losses and reputational damage.

Types of Supply Chain Risks:

There are different types of supply chain risks, each with its characteristics and potential impacts. Supply chain vulnerabilities include:

  • Operational Risks: Risks related to internal operations, such as manufacturing disruptions, equipment failures, or labor issues.
  • Financial Risks: Risks associated with the transportation and storage of goods, including delays, damages, and logistical inefficiencies.
  • Environmental Risks: Natural disasters like earthquakes, floods, or extreme weather conditions that disrupt supply chains.
  • Geopolitical Risks: Risks arising from political instability, trade wars, or changes in government policies that affect the supply chain.
  • Technological Risks: Risks related to technology failures or cyber-attacks that impact data and operational security.

Supply Chain Risk Identification and Assessment

The first step in effective SCRM is identifying and assessing potential risks across your supply chain. This process involves:

  • Risk Identification: Gathering data and insights from various sources, including market trends, historical data, and supplier information, to identify potential risk factors
  • Risk Analysis: Evaluating identified supply chain attack risks to understand their potential impact on the supply chain, including assessing the severity of each risk and its possible consequences
  • Risk Prioritization: Prioritizing risks based on their potential impact and likelihood helps in allocating resources effectively to address the most critical risks, preventing supply chain disruptions

Supply Chain Risk Mitigation

After identifying and assessing the risks, the next critical step is mitigating them. Supply chain risk mitigation involves creating flexibility and resilience in the supply chain, which helps ensure that businesses can continue operating effectively even during disruptions.

By understanding and implementing effective mitigation techniques, businesses can protect themselves against potential threats throughout the supply chain life cycle, thereby maintaining supply chain resilience and a competitive edge. Risk mitigation strategies in SCRM include:

  1. Developing Contingency Plans: Creating plans for how to respond to various risk scenarios, including backup suppliers, alternative transportation routes, and emergency response protocols for critical infrastructure
  2. Building Resilience: Strengthening the supply chain to withstand disruptions, which involves diversifying suppliers, investing in robust technology systems, and improving inventory management for sustainability
  3. Monitoring and Review: Continuously monitoring the supply chain for new risks and reviewing the effectiveness of mitigation strategies through regular audits and updating plans as necessary

Supply Chain Security Management Explained

Supply Chain Security Management (SCSM) is a specialized field that protects supply chains from various security risks, such as theft, fraud, terrorism, and cyberattacks.

Unlike general risk management, SCSM specifically deals with intentional acts that could cause harm or disruption to the supply chain. This category of supply chain management is essential in maintaining the integrity, continuity, and reliability of supply chain operations.

Security-Related Supply Chain Risks

Supply chains face various security risks that require specific strategies to mitigate and manage them while ensuring their security. Examples of such security risks include:

  1. Theft: Risks of goods being stolen during manufacturing, storage, or transportation
  2. Cybersecurity Threats: Risks such as data breaches, malware, hackers, and cyber attacks that may result in compromised sensitive information or disrupted supply chain operations
  3. Counterfeiting and Fraud: Risks involving the production and distribution of counterfeit goods or fraudulent activities within the supply chain
  4. Terrorism and Vandalism: Risks from intentional acts aimed at causing harm or disrupting supply chain operations
  5. Regulatory Compliance Risks: Risks related to non-compliance with international trade regulations, resulting in penalties and operational delays

Supply Chain Security Measures

Supply chain security management is a crucial aspect of any business that deals with goods delivery. It requires a comprehensive approach that combines physical security measures, technological solutions, employee training, and strict compliance protocols.

By adopting these measures, businesses can protect their supply chains from various security threats, ensuring a safe and smooth flow of goods from suppliers to customers. Examples of supply chain security measures include:

  1. Physical Security Measures: Secured warehousing, controlled access to facilities, security personnel, and surveillance systems to prevent theft and vandalism
  2. Cybersecurity Protocols: Robust cybersecurity measures such as firewalls, encryption, secure communication channels, and regular security audits to protect against cyber threats and cyber supply chain risk. Consider utilizing cybersecurity frameworks from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) as a starting point.
  3. Employee Training and Vigilance: Training employees on security protocols and vigilance to detect and report suspicious activities.
  4. Supply Chain Visibility: Using technology to gain real-time visibility into the entire supply chain to identify and respond to security threats quickly.
  5. Compliance Management: Ensuring adherence to international trade regulations and standards and implementing measures to avoid compliance-related risks.

Securing Your Supply Chain with SCRM and SCSM

Securing a supply chain is no longer just about managing individual risks or enhancing national security in isolation. The best way to secure a supply chain is to integrate both supply chain risk management and supply chain security management to create a comprehensive defense strategy. This integrated approach ensures the smooth operation of supply chain activities and safeguards against potential security breaches and disruptions.

By combining the principles of SCRM and SCSM, businesses can build a resilient, adaptable, and secure supply chain ecosystem. Below are five ways to secure your supply chain with SCRM and SCSM. Each section includes individual SCRM and SCSM components and an integrated practice that can be applied to your organization’s supply chain management program.

Comprehensive Risk Assessment and Continuous Monitoring

Comprehensive risk assessment and continuous monitoring involve identifying potential risks like market fluctuations, supplier instability, cybersecurity threats, and theft, providing businesses with real-time insights into these risks.

  • SCRM Component: Regular and thorough risk assessments must be conducted to identify potential vulnerabilities in the supply chain. This includes evaluating supplier risks, geopolitical risks, market volatility, and other operational risks
  • SCSM Component: Extend the assessment to security-specific risks like theft, cyber-attacks, fraud, and counterfeiting
  • Integrated Practice: Implement a continuous monitoring system to track risk indicators and trigger alerts for potential disruptions and security breaches, utilizing technologies such as AI and machine learning for real-time risk analysis

Diversification and Redundancy in Supply Chain

Diversification, redundancy, due diligence, and backup plans can help companies mitigate risks, reduce reliance on single entities, and ensure operational continuity. These measures can protect businesses from disruptions and maintain a stable operation.

  • SCRM Component: Diversify suppliers and logistics partners to avoid over-reliance on a single source, which can be a significant risk in case of disruptions
  • SCSM Component: Implement redundancy across critical supply chain elements like multiple transportation routes, backup suppliers, and emergency response plans for security incidents
  • Integrated Practice: Create a flexible supply chain model that can adapt and reroute operations swiftly in response to both risk and security challenges

Robust Cybersecurity Measures

Strong cybersecurity is crucial for supply chain operations. Comprehensive protocols, regular audits, and constant updates are needed to safeguard against evolving threats. Protecting sensitive data is vital for maintaining trust within the supply chain network.

Collaboration and Transparency with Partners

Collaboration with suppliers and partners, sharing risk information, developing joint strategies, transparent communication, and training programs enhance the supply chain's resilience and security.

  • SCRM Component: Foster strong relationships with suppliers and partners to improve communication, collaboration, and joint decision-making, which enhances the ability to identify and manage risks collaboratively
  • SCSM Component: Work with supply chain partners to ensure that they adhere to security standards and practices, including physical security measures and employee vetting processes
  • Integrated Practice: Develop a shared platform or system for real-time information sharing and collaboration among all stakeholders, enhancing both risk management and security response capabilities

Training and Awareness Programs

Regular training on risk management, security protocols, and emergency procedures ensures a proactive and vigilant workforce. Awareness campaigns and a culture of security and risk across the entire company (e.g., cybersecurity, information technology, procurement/acquisition, legal, etc.) ensure every member contributes to the supply chain's resilience and security.

  • SCRM Component: Train employees and stakeholders in identifying and managing various supply chain risks, emphasizing the importance of proactive risk management
  • SCSM Component: Include specific training on security protocols, such as recognizing potential security threats, proper handling of sensitive information, and response procedures in case of security incidents
  • Integrated Practice: Regularly conduct training and simulation exercises that cover both risk management and security scenarios, ensuring all personnel are prepared to respond effectively to a range of supply chain challenges

Enhance Your Organization’s Supply Chain Management with UpGuard

Protecting your supply chain can be overwhelming—luckily, UpGuard is here to help. With UpGuard's cybersecurity tools, BreachSight and Vendor Risk, you can manage your external attack surface and third-party vendors, gain insights into the risks affecting your external security posture, and ensure your assets are constantly monitored and protected.

Other features include:

  • Data Leak Detection: Protect your brand, intellectual property, and customer data with timely detection of data leaks and avoid data breaches
  • Continuous Monitoring: Get real-time information and manage exposures, including domains, IPs, and employee credentials
  • Attack Surface Reduction: Reduce your attack surface by discovering exploitable vulnerabilities and domains at risk of typosquatting
  • Shared Security Profile: Eliminate having to answer security questionnaires by creating an UpGuard Shared Profile
  • Workflows and Waivers: Simplify and accelerate how you remediate issues, waive risks, and respond to security queries
  • Reporting and Insights: Access tailor-made reports for different stakeholders and view information about your external attack surface
  • Security Questionnaires: Automate security questionnaires with workflows to get deeper insights into your vendors’ security
  • Security Ratings: Instantly understand your vendors' security posture with our data-driven, objective, and dynamic security ratings
  • Risk Assessments: Let us guide you each step of the way, from gathering evidence, assessing risks, and requesting remediation
  • Monitoring Vendor Risk: Monitor your vendors daily and view the details to understand what risks are impacting a vendor’s security posture
  • Managed Third-Party Risks: Let our expert analysts manage your third-party risk management program and allocate your security resources

Ready to see
UpGuard in action?