When organizations hear “third-party risk management,” they often consider the processes needed to mitigate risks when working with a third-party vendor. These can include procurement risks and risks associated with starting new vendor relationships, often referred to as "onboarding,”—but what about when a working relationship ends?
Vendor offboarding is often overlooked when considering third-party risk management but is crucial to the vendor lifecycle and third-party relationships. Many risks during the offboarding process can potentially impact your organization, leading to loss of finances, damaged reputation, or cybersecurity incidents like data breaches.
This blog post will explore the best practices for ensuring security while offboarding vendors, including what type of security risks offboarding presents and management solutions you can take to mitigate them the next time your organization goes through the offboarding process.
What is Vendor Offboarding?
Vendor offboarding formally ends a working relationship with a third-party supplier or service provider. This process ties up loose ends and mitigates potential risks when discontinuing a vendor's services.
Effective vendor offboarding is as critical as onboarding since overlooking certain steps can lead to security vulnerabilities, financial discrepancies, and other complications. Therefore, paying close attention is important to ensure the vendor offboarding process is carried out properly.
Security Risks when Offboarding Vendors
During the offboarding process, there are a variety of security risks organizations must be aware of and manage. These risks can become data breaches, unauthorized access to systems or networks, and other vulnerabilities if they do not. Below are some examples of the security risks involved with offboarding vendors.
Access Control and Management
Access control and management are two of the biggest areas of concern around offboarding third-party vendors. Vendors may access your organization’s critical systems and networks, physical office spaces, and even sensitive information during the working relationship. When that working relationship ends, and offboarding begins, that access must be revoked promptly to prevent unauthorized access. Examples of access management risks include:
- Residual Access: If a vendor’s access to systems, applications, and networks is not completely revoked, that residual access could allow them unauthorized access to sensitive data or systems.
- Shared Credentials: While not a best practice, some organizations may have utilized shared credentials with vendors. If these are not changed after offboarding, they pose another risk of unauthorized access and other cyber risks.
- Physical Security: Vendors may have been issued methods like badges or keys to access your organization's physical office or location. If these are not revoked or deactivated during offboarding, they present a risk of unauthorized physical access.
Data Security and Handling
While working with third-party vendors, organizations often share data during typical business operations. Sometimes, this data can be highly sensitive, and if leaked during a data breach, it could have devasting consequences. Data privacy and information security is also a priority during the offboarding process, as there are multiple types of risks around data security and handling, including:
- Data Retention: Data breaches may occur if a vendor has obtained any company data or intellectual property and fails to delete it during offboarding.
- Lack of Data Encryption: More data may be exchanged between the organization and the vendor during offboarding. Without adequate encryption, that data becomes vulnerable during transit or at rest, which could lead to unauthorized access or data breaches.
- Unreturned Assets: If a vendor was provided with company assets such as laptops, software, or other items, they must be returned during the offboarding process to prevent potential data leaks.
Documentation and Communication
When offboarding, organizations must securely document and communicate about former vendors. This includes both internal security teams and external stakeholders who interact with vendors. Failing to communicate about vendor offboarding properly can lead to a variety of risks, including:
- Outdated Documentation: Not keeping documentation up-to-date can result in confusion and security lapses, such as employees considering onboarding vendors as valid points of contact or trust.
- Miscommunication: If an organization does not communicate clearly about vendor departures, there is a risk of unintentional information disclosure or other security breaches.
Contractual and Compliance Issues
Vendor contracts and compliance are integral to the ongoing relationship between vendor and organization. However, when that working relationship ends, organizations must continue to pay attention to contract termination and compliance requirements as they offboard the vendor. There are a variety of contractual and compliance issues organizations can face during vendor offboarding, including:
- Unfulfilled Contractual Obligations: Not paying attention to security, data handling, and confidentiality contract clauses can result in legal, compliance, and financial risks.
- Lack of Audit Trails: Unauthorized access or malicious activities by the vendor may go unnoticed without proper logs and monitoring.
- Dependencies: Dependent systems and processes may become vulnerable without alternative solutions or updates from the vendor.
Human Factors and Malicious Threats
While most security risks during vendor offboarding occur online or within digital spaces, human factors and other malicious threats must not be underestimated. These risks can also result in security incidents like data breaches or unauthorized access. Some risks originating from human factors or malicious threats include:
- Revenge or Malicious Intent: If a vendor relationship ends on bad terms, it may lead to malicious actions from the vendor’s side that negatively impact the primary organization.
- Embedded Systems or Services: If a vendor has integrated tools, apps, or systems in your infrastructure and left them behind, they can become vulnerable or susceptible to hackers if not properly decommissioned.
- Third-Party Risks: An offboarded vendor may have third parties, posing indirect risks if not considered during offboarding.
Best Practices for Reducing Risk When Offboarding Vendors
Offboarding third-party vendors is an essential step in the lifecycle of vendor management. Properly managing the end of a vendor relationship can prevent potential security breaches and data loss. Below are some best practices to consider during the vendor offboarding process.
Process and Communication
When offboarding vendors, use a personalized approach and develop customized offboarding procedures that meet each vendor type's specific needs and requirements. This ensures consistency and effectiveness while also helping to minimize any potential risks or oversights.
Maintaining organizational communication is also essential to smooth operations and preventing disruptions. By promptly notifying the relevant teams and stakeholders about the vendor's termination, the organization can better prepare for the transition and handle all aspects of the process with attention to detail and due diligence.
Access control is a vital component of best practices for offboarding vendors and critical for safeguarding an organization's digital and physical assets. When the relationship with a vendor ends, it is important that all access points—including digital portals, databases, applications, physical entrances, and facilities—are thoroughly reviewed and disabled. Implementing multi-layered access control systems, both technologically and manually, helps pinpoint and turn off any residual permissions, preventing unauthorized entry or data breaches.
Regularly audit and update these controls per the offboarding process. By doing so, businesses can ensure their security integrity, reduce risks, and protect against potential vulnerabilities from former vendor associations.
Asset and Data Management
Proper asset and data management preserves a company's proprietary assets and information confidentiality. The first step in this process is to retrieve company property, which includes ensuring that all hardware, software, data, and other critical assets previously in the vendor's possession are returned promptly and completely.
Simultaneously, it is essential to maintain rigorous vigilance in data management to ensure that vendors have securely deleted any residual data from their systems, eliminating the possibility of any unauthorized copies or leaks. Legal oversight in this process provides an added layer of protection, ensuring that all data-related offboarding actions comply with contractual stipulations and broader data protection regulations. By following these steps, organizations can fortify their defenses and ensure a seamless and secure transition as the vendor relationship concludes.
Audits and Monitoring
Audits are critical to ensure systems remain uncompromised when a vendor relationship ends. A thorough check for residual access or data is vital to prevent latent vulnerabilities and potential breaches. Reviewing system logs can help shed light on the vendor's recent activities and is equally important to ensure that no automated tasks still operate using the vendor's credentials.
Continuous monitoring becomes essential after the audit, particularly in the initial phase after offboarding. Vigilance over systems helps detect unauthorized access attempts, crucial to maintaining data integrity and countering potential security threats. While audits provide a snapshot of security at a given time, ongoing monitoring is a consistent safeguard, ensuring the systems remain secure even after the vendor departs.
Documentation and Dependencies
When offboarding vendors, it is crucial to focus on documentation and dependencies. Updating internal documentation is the first step, ensuring that any changes resulting from the end of the vendor relationship are accurately reflected. This includes removing any references to the vendor so that internal teams have a clear and up-to-date understanding of system configurations and procedures.
Reviewing dependencies is equally important. Organizations should proactively identify systems, processes, or operations that previously relied on the vendor. Once identified, these dependencies should be addressed promptly by transitioning to alternative solutions or making necessary adjustments to ensure business continuity and minimize potential operational disruptions.
Contractual and Legal Oversight
Focusing on contractual and legal oversight is important when offboarding a vendor to ensure a smooth and seamless transition. A thorough review of the existing contract is crucial to achieve this. This includes examining the clauses related to data return, verifying that the vendor has followed the agreed-upon data destruction protocols, and ensuring that all confidentiality commitments remain in effect even after the partnership ends.
Alongside these critical data considerations, it is essential to address the financial aspect comprehensively. This involves resolving all financial settlements, such as final payments, penalties, and other monetary matters. Doing so clears potential financial liabilities and ensures that the vendor relationship ends on a clean slate.
Data Backup and Security Protocols
When offboarding vendors, it is essential to prioritize data backup and security protocols to protect the organization's interests. The first step is to backup and archive all critical data related to the vendor's services and store it securely. This helps ensure that important information remains accessible and intact, thus preventing any potential losses or mishaps.
Additionally, the offboarding process requires updating the organization's incident response plan. As the vendor relationship ends, it is necessary to modify any protocols, contacts, or response measures linked to the vendor. This will ensure that outdated or irrelevant procedures do not hinder the organization's response to a security incident. The organization can respond quickly and effectively to a security breach by doing so.
Upgrade your Third-Party Risk Management with UpGuard
Whether onboarding new vendors, revising your working relationships with current vendors, or offboarding vendors, third-party risk management should always be top of mind. UpGuard is here to help your organization take your TPRM program to the next level.
UpGuard Vendor Risk is our all-in-one management platform that streamlines your organization’s Vendor Risk Management processes. Vendor Risk allows you to automate your third-party risk assessment workflows and get real-time notifications about your vendors’ security in one centralized dashboard. Additional Vendor Risk features include:
- Security Questionnaires: Automate security questionnaires with workflows to get deeper insights into your vendors’ security
- Security Ratings: Instantly understand your vendors' security posture with our data-driven, objective, and dynamic security ratings
- Risk Assessments: Let us guide you each step of the way, from gathering evidence, assessing risks, and requesting remediation
- Monitoring Vendor Risk: Monitor your vendors daily and view the details to understand what risks are impacting a vendor’s security posture
- Reporting and Insights: UpGuard’s Reports Library makes it easier and faster for you to access tailor-made reports for different stakeholders
- Managed Third-Party Risks: Let our expert analysts manage your third-party risk management program and allocate your security resources
- Transparent Pricing: UpGuard has a transparent pricing model, which you can view here.