Panorays vs SecurityScorecard: 2025 Comparison

Panorays vs SecurityScorecard
Category	UpGuard	Panorays	SecurityScorecard
General summary	UpGuard manages cyber risk everywhere it lives: your vendors, your internet-facing attack surface, and your workforce. You get one platform that connects all three risk areas instead of separate tools and spreadsheets stitched together. A risk in one surfaces in the others automatically. A breached vendor flags your own exposure. A leaked employee credential links straight to the account and the vendor involved. AI handles the repetitive work of triaging alerts, reviewing vendor evidence, and completing questionnaires. That means lean security teams can run programs that would otherwise need much bigger teams. UpGuard fits mid-market teams, deploys quickly, and slots in without replacing what you already have.	Panorays is an IT Vendor Risk Management solution focused on security ratings, vendor assessments, and automated questionnaire workflows. It combines external attack surface monitoring and vendor risk questionnaires, delivering comprehensive visibility into vendor security postures. Panorays specializes in providing clear, unified security ratings and simplifying the vendor onboarding process, though it lacks fully real-time monitoring capabilities.	SecurityScorecard is a cybersecurity ratings platform that monitors external-facing vendor networks. It aggregates risk signals from various sources to produce vendor security ratings. SecurityScorecard integrates with SIEM and GRC tools and provides insights that mitigate supply chain attacks. However, risk assessment workflows are managed separately via the Atlas module, which can lead to fragmented processes that could delay vendor assessment delivery and impact program efficiency.
Key strengths	UpGuard unifies vendor, attack surface, and workforce risk in one console. Customers describe finally seeing the whole picture, rather than paying for three tools that each cover only part of it. UpGuard also surfaces exposures that ratings tools and scanners miss, without the multi-week delay of a typical scan cycle. Lean teams can run the entire program without expanding headcount or adding a managed service.	Panorays excels in automated questionnaire workflows, simplifying vendor assessments and onboarding processes. Its unified security rating system effectively quantifies external and internal vendor risks, delivering valuable insights to executive stakeholders. The platform integrates external scans, questionnaires, and certifications into auditable security attestations.	SecurityScorecard covers an extensive range of cyber intelligence, drawing from open, proprietary, and dark web sources to identify vendor security risks and assess IP reputation risks. SecurityScorecard's well-known A-F letter grade system makes it approachable for executives and large enterprises.
Key weaknesses	UpGuard focuses on managing live, connected risk, not heavy, standalone compliance software. Full governance features, including policy and controls management, arrive later this year. Teams that need a mature governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) system of record today can run UpGuard alongside one for now. UpGuard also doesn’t translate risk into dollar figures. If financial risk quantification is a must-have, factor that into your evaluation.	Panorays underperforms in its reporting capabilities, offering limited options for customizing reports and dashboards. The platform does not natively support TPRM workflows, forcing customers to purchase additional tools to fill TPRM process gaps.	SecurityScorecard's staggered scan cycles disrupts real-time vendor security posture visibility. IP attribution issues are also cited as common scanning problems. Additionally, vendor monitoring and risk assessments are licensed separately, which may increase purchasing complexity and limit coverage of end-to-end visibility of supply chain vendors.
Usability and learning curve	Teams deploy quickly and get up and running without an extended onboarding period. New employees can learn the interface without lengthy training. A single console consolidates workflows that would otherwise require multiple tools, reducing the ongoing burden of learning and maintaining separate systems. Operating the platform doesn’t require a professional services engagement.	Panorays offers a user-friendly platform with automated workflows and straightforward vendor onboarding, making it relatively easy for teams to adopt. However, the complex structure of optional questionnaire responses and segmented refresh rates for monitoring can introduce minor learning curve challenges, particularly for teams new to Vendor Risk Management practices.	SecurityScorecard's dashboards and clear A-F grading help non-technical stakeholders quickly grasp vendor risk exposure. However, some users report multiple drill-down steps required to reach specific risk insights, which could lengthen new user learning curves.
Cyber risk data accuracy	UpGuard’s data remains current. Vendor postures refresh continuously, and users can initiate a scan on demand instead of waiting for a fixed cycle. UpGuard attributes findings accurately, so teams do not spend weeks correcting assets assigned to the wrong company, a common issue with ratings tools. Threat Monitoring scans the open, deep, and dark web, along with social media, for leaked data, exposed credentials, and brand impersonation. AI filters out noise so the alerts that reach your team are worth acting on.	The accuracy of Panorays' cyber risk insights could be improved by including technical information about sources for all identified risks	SecurityScorecard offers extensive data collection across public-facing and dark web sources, though users occasionally report inaccurate attribution or misflagged IPs requiring support.
Vendor risk management features	UpGuard runs the complete third-party risk management (TPRM) process in one platform: onboarding, assessing, remediating, monitoring, and reporting on vendors. Each vendor’s live external exposure and any linked leaked credentials appear directly within the vendor program, so teams can act on verified risk instead of relying on paperwork. AI-powered security questionnaires read vendor evidence and complete assessments automatically, cutting completion time by up to 95%. Instant risk assessments return a point-in-time report in under a minute, mapped to frameworks like ISO 27001 and NIST CSF 2.0.	Panorays includes comprehensive Vendor Risk Management capabilities such as automated questionnaire workflows, security rating integration, and simplified onboarding management. The platform effectively manages the assessment lifecycle but falls short in providing continuous real-time vendor risk monitoring, potentially requiring supplementary solutions for deeper insights. Its questionnaire design includes numerous optional questions, which often results in vendors skipping responses, potentially weakening the overall risk assessment quality.	SecurityScorecard's VRM workflow requires a separate module named Atlas for security questionnaire and risk assessment processes. This can introduce complexity into this process.
Attack surface management features	UpGuard continuously monitors your internet-facing footprint. It maps assets, flags exposures such as misconfigurations, expired certificates, and open ports, and ranks remediation priorities. The UpGuard platform also detects typosquatting and lookalike domains set up to impersonate your brand before they’re used for phishing. Because attack surface monitoring runs alongside vendor and workforce risk, an exposed asset or leaked credential automatically links to the person and vendor involved. This gives teams visibility into both external exposure and vendor risk in a single view.	Panorays effectively identifies and monitors vendor external attack surfaces through periodic scanning intervals. The platform identifies exposed assets and potential vulnerabilities, supporting risk management through visibility and remediation recommendations.	SecurityScorecard offers views into an organization's attack surface by leveraging IP scanning and attribution of identified domains and assets. The platform's approach helps users identify potential weaknesses in their digital footprint that an attacker might exploit.
Customer support	UpGuard supports every customer across all plan tiers, from the smallest plan to the largest. Support teams assist with both technical setup and larger program decisions. Customers frequently cite responsive, hands-on support as a reason they continue with UpGuard.	Some users have reported unsatisfactory customer support. Given Panorays' smaller customer base compared to other competitors, this is likely due to resource constraints.	Generally supportive for enterprise levels, with a community of free users. However, customers at lower licensing tiers report slower responses and less personalized support.
Workflow automation	Risk Automations turns a risk signal into action across the platform, with no code and no engineering ticket. On the vendor side, it automates onboarding from questionnaire data, triages vendor score drops, schedules recurring vendor reports, and opens remediation tickets in ServiceNow or Jira. On the threat side, a Breach Risk detection can trigger a workflow that alerts Teams or Slack and runs a system-level fix, like blocking a malicious IP or forcing a credential reset. This is the difference between a tool that reports on risk and one that resolves it.	Panorays leverages automation effectively for vendor onboarding, questionnaire management, and security attestation workflows. Automated questionnaires streamline data collection and risk assessment processes. However, deeper integration and more advanced automation capabilities, particularly those involving continuous real-time monitoring, may necessitate additional configuration or supplemental solutions.	SecurityScorecard's workflow automation features let users create rule-based triggers that automatically respond to security events, such as score drops, new high-severity issues, or breaches. Users can choose from a range of automated response actions, including alert activation, report sharing, and reassigning scorecards for further review
Artificial intelligence features	UpGuard’s AI performs specific, defined tasks, rather than vague “AI-powered” work. The AI Threat Analyst sorts and scores incoming threats across your attack surface, the dark web, and social media. It clears out approximately 60% of alerts as noise, so your team only reviews what matters. The same triage logic extends to vendor and workforce signals as well. Every AI result carries a citation back to the source, so your team can verify it before acting.	Panorays utilizes AI primarily to automate and pre-fill questionnaire responses, reducing manual effort and enhancing assessment efficiency. However, including optional questionnaire items somewhat diminishes the AI's effectiveness, as incomplete vendor responses can affect overall risk visibility and the depth of insights generated.	SecurityScorecard offers a branded AI capability named HEID. HEID’s operational workflows are primarily geared toward SecurityScoreCard's MAX managed service offering, with claims that AI can generate automated remediation and questionnaire requests as risks arise. SecurityScorecard claims that HEID AI is available as a backend capability for customers with non-service plans, and it is used in its algorithms for risk scoring and classification of issue criticality.
API and integrations	A well-documented REST API and webhooks let teams pull risk data into their own tools and trigger actions programmatically, without waiting on engineering support. For no-code work, Risk Automations adds more than 100 native integrations, including Jira, ServiceNow, Microsoft Entra, Slack, and Cloudflare. A Universal API Connector Node extends its reach to any open API.	Panorays includes core integrations such as SSO and API access, particularly at higher-tier subscription levels. Additional specialized integrations or advanced API functionalities may incur extra costs. The platform offers straightforward connectivity options but may require supplemental investments for extensive customization or complex integrations.	SecurityScoreCard offers an extensive marketplace of integrations with security, GRC, and workflow platforms. However, integrations tend to primarily focus on score visibility in other platforms rather than workflow extensibility. Offers integrations with several third-party platforms, such as RSA Archer, ServiceNow, and more.
Purchasing & licensing transparency	UpGuard publishes its pricing rather than hiding it behind a sales call. A free tier lets teams monitor up to five vendors and use Trust Exchange, UpGuard’s AI-powered questionnaire tool, at no cost. Paid Vendor Risk plans start at USD 1,750 per month, billed annually. Teams can start with one product and add others as they scale. One license covers both monitoring and assessments, so pricing doesn’t fragment across separate products.	Panorays offers a free plan for assessing up to five vendors and a full-featured free trial. However, detailed public pricing information is not disclosed, and users must contact sales directly for tailored quotes. Panorays features a complex pricing structure involving multiple service tiers (Continuous 360° Evaluation, Bi-Annual 360° Evaluation, Continuous Posture Evaluation, Bi-Annual Posture Evaluation, Smart Questionnaires), potentially complicating purchasing decisions and budget forecasting	Public pricing information is not available. Offers a free plan and a 14-day free trial for paid plans.
Customers	UpGuard customers include Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE), Morningstar, TDK, PagerDuty, Hopin, and IAG. Read UpGuard’s customer stories to learn more.	Major customers include Avis, Arvest, Quantum, and Payoneer.	Major customers include Hershey, Cleveland Clinic, Avangrid, and ADT.
G2 rating Accurate as of March 2025	More than 700 verified reviews give UpGuard a 4.5 out of 5 rating on G2. UpGuard also holds G2’s top ranking as the leader in Third-Party & Supplier Risk Management for 15 consecutive quarters. The 2026 G2 Best Software Awards recognized UpGuard as one of the Top 100 Global Software Companies. Among verified reviewers, 98% give UpGuard four- or five-star ratings, and 94% approve of its product direction.	4.3, based on 35 reviews.	4.2, based on 75 reviews.
Security ratings	943 / 950	833 / 950	802 / 950

General summary

UpGuard manages cyber risk everywhere it lives: your vendors, your internet-facing attack surface, and your workforce. You get one platform that connects all three risk areas instead of separate tools and spreadsheets stitched together. A risk in one surfaces in the others automatically. A breached vendor flags your own exposure. A leaked employee credential links straight to the account and the vendor involved. AI handles the repetitive work of triaging alerts, reviewing vendor evidence, and completing questionnaires. That means lean security teams can run programs that would otherwise need much bigger teams. UpGuard fits mid-market teams, deploys quickly, and slots in without replacing what you already have.

Panorays is an IT Vendor Risk Management solution focused on security ratings, vendor assessments, and automated questionnaire workflows. It combines external attack surface monitoring and vendor risk questionnaires, delivering comprehensive visibility into vendor security postures. Panorays specializes in providing clear, unified security ratings and simplifying the vendor onboarding process, though it lacks fully real-time monitoring capabilities.

SecurityScorecard is a cybersecurity ratings platform that monitors external-facing vendor networks. It aggregates risk signals from various sources to produce vendor security ratings. SecurityScorecard integrates with SIEM and GRC tools and provides insights that mitigate supply chain attacks. However, risk assessment workflows are managed separately via the Atlas module, which can lead to fragmented processes that could delay vendor assessment delivery and impact program efficiency.

Key strengths

UpGuard unifies vendor, attack surface, and workforce risk in one console. Customers describe finally seeing the whole picture, rather than paying for three tools that each cover only part of it. UpGuard also surfaces exposures that ratings tools and scanners miss, without the multi-week delay of a typical scan cycle. Lean teams can run the entire program without expanding headcount or adding a managed service.

Panorays excels in automated questionnaire workflows, simplifying vendor assessments and onboarding processes. Its unified security rating system effectively quantifies external and internal vendor risks, delivering valuable insights to executive stakeholders. The platform integrates external scans, questionnaires, and certifications into auditable security attestations.

SecurityScorecard covers an extensive range of cyber intelligence, drawing from open, proprietary, and dark web sources to identify vendor security risks and assess IP reputation risks. SecurityScorecard's well-known A-F letter grade system makes it approachable for executives and large enterprises.

Key weaknesses

UpGuard focuses on managing live, connected risk, not heavy, standalone compliance software. Full governance features, including policy and controls management, arrive later this year. Teams that need a mature governance, risk, and compliance (GRC) system of record today can run UpGuard alongside one for now. UpGuard also doesn’t translate risk into dollar figures. If financial risk quantification is a must-have, factor that into your evaluation.

Panorays underperforms in its reporting capabilities, offering limited options for customizing reports and dashboards. The platform does not natively support TPRM workflows, forcing customers to purchase additional tools to fill TPRM process gaps.

SecurityScorecard's staggered scan cycles disrupts real-time vendor security posture visibility. IP attribution issues are also cited as common scanning problems. Additionally, vendor monitoring and risk assessments are licensed separately, which may increase purchasing complexity and limit coverage of end-to-end visibility of supply chain vendors.

Usability and learning curve

Teams deploy quickly and get up and running without an extended onboarding period. New employees can learn the interface without lengthy training. A single console consolidates workflows that would otherwise require multiple tools, reducing the ongoing burden of learning and maintaining separate systems. Operating the platform doesn’t require a professional services engagement.

Panorays offers a user-friendly platform with automated workflows and straightforward vendor onboarding, making it relatively easy for teams to adopt. However, the complex structure of optional questionnaire responses and segmented refresh rates for monitoring can introduce minor learning curve challenges, particularly for teams new to Vendor Risk Management practices.

SecurityScorecard's dashboards and clear A-F grading help non-technical stakeholders quickly grasp vendor risk exposure. However, some users report multiple drill-down steps required to reach specific risk insights, which could lengthen new user learning curves.

Cyber risk data accuracy

UpGuard’s data remains current. Vendor postures refresh continuously, and users can initiate a scan on demand instead of waiting for a fixed cycle. UpGuard attributes findings accurately, so teams do not spend weeks correcting assets assigned to the wrong company, a common issue with ratings tools. Threat Monitoring scans the open, deep, and dark web, along with social media, for leaked data, exposed credentials, and brand impersonation. AI filters out noise so the alerts that reach your team are worth acting on.

The accuracy of Panorays' cyber risk insights could be improved by including technical information about sources for all identified risks

SecurityScorecard offers extensive data collection across public-facing and dark web sources, though users occasionally report inaccurate attribution or misflagged IPs requiring support.

Vendor risk management features

UpGuard runs the complete third-party risk management (TPRM) process in one platform: onboarding, assessing, remediating, monitoring, and reporting on vendors. Each vendor’s live external exposure and any linked leaked credentials appear directly within the vendor program, so teams can act on verified risk instead of relying on paperwork. AI-powered security questionnaires read vendor evidence and complete assessments automatically, cutting completion time by up to 95%. Instant risk assessments return a point-in-time report in under a minute, mapped to frameworks like ISO 27001 and NIST CSF 2.0.

Panorays includes comprehensive Vendor Risk Management capabilities such as automated questionnaire workflows, security rating integration, and simplified onboarding management. The platform effectively manages the assessment lifecycle but falls short in providing continuous real-time vendor risk monitoring, potentially requiring supplementary solutions for deeper insights. Its questionnaire design includes numerous optional questions, which often results in vendors skipping responses, potentially weakening the overall risk assessment quality.

SecurityScorecard's VRM workflow requires a separate module named Atlas for security questionnaire and risk assessment processes. This can introduce complexity into this process.

Attack surface management features

UpGuard continuously monitors your internet-facing footprint. It maps assets, flags exposures such as misconfigurations, expired certificates, and open ports, and ranks remediation priorities. The UpGuard platform also detects typosquatting and lookalike domains set up to impersonate your brand before they’re used for phishing. Because attack surface monitoring runs alongside vendor and workforce risk, an exposed asset or leaked credential automatically links to the person and vendor involved. This gives teams visibility into both external exposure and vendor risk in a single view.

Panorays effectively identifies and monitors vendor external attack surfaces through periodic scanning intervals. The platform identifies exposed assets and potential vulnerabilities, supporting risk management through visibility and remediation recommendations.

SecurityScorecard offers views into an organization's attack surface by leveraging IP scanning and attribution of identified domains and assets. The platform's approach helps users identify potential weaknesses in their digital footprint that an attacker might exploit.

Customer support

UpGuard supports every customer across all plan tiers, from the smallest plan to the largest. Support teams assist with both technical setup and larger program decisions. Customers frequently cite responsive, hands-on support as a reason they continue with UpGuard.

Some users have reported unsatisfactory customer support. Given Panorays' smaller customer base compared to other competitors, this is likely due to resource constraints.

Generally supportive for enterprise levels, with a community of free users. However, customers at lower licensing tiers report slower responses and less personalized support.

Workflow automation

Risk Automations turns a risk signal into action across the platform, with no code and no engineering ticket. On the vendor side, it automates onboarding from questionnaire data, triages vendor score drops, schedules recurring vendor reports, and opens remediation tickets in ServiceNow or Jira. On the threat side, a Breach Risk detection can trigger a workflow that alerts Teams or Slack and runs a system-level fix, like blocking a malicious IP or forcing a credential reset. This is the difference between a tool that reports on risk and one that resolves it.

Panorays leverages automation effectively for vendor onboarding, questionnaire management, and security attestation workflows. Automated questionnaires streamline data collection and risk assessment processes. However, deeper integration and more advanced automation capabilities, particularly those involving continuous real-time monitoring, may necessitate additional configuration or supplemental solutions.

SecurityScorecard's workflow automation features let users create rule-based triggers that automatically respond to security events, such as score drops, new high-severity issues, or breaches. Users can choose from a range of automated response actions, including alert activation, report sharing, and reassigning scorecards for further review

Artificial intelligence features

UpGuard’s AI performs specific, defined tasks, rather than vague “AI-powered” work. The AI Threat Analyst sorts and scores incoming threats across your attack surface, the dark web, and social media. It clears out approximately 60% of alerts as noise, so your team only reviews what matters. The same triage logic extends to vendor and workforce signals as well. Every AI result carries a citation back to the source, so your team can verify it before acting.

Panorays utilizes AI primarily to automate and pre-fill questionnaire responses, reducing manual effort and enhancing assessment efficiency. However, including optional questionnaire items somewhat diminishes the AI's effectiveness, as incomplete vendor responses can affect overall risk visibility and the depth of insights generated.

SecurityScorecard offers a branded AI capability named HEID. HEID’s operational workflows are primarily geared toward SecurityScoreCard's MAX managed service offering, with claims that AI can generate automated remediation and questionnaire requests as risks arise. SecurityScorecard claims that HEID AI is available as a backend capability for customers with non-service plans, and it is used in its algorithms for risk scoring and classification of issue criticality.

API and integrations

A well-documented REST API and webhooks let teams pull risk data into their own tools and trigger actions programmatically, without waiting on engineering support. For no-code work, Risk Automations adds more than 100 native integrations, including Jira, ServiceNow, Microsoft Entra, Slack, and Cloudflare. A Universal API Connector Node extends its reach to any open API.

Panorays includes core integrations such as SSO and API access, particularly at higher-tier subscription levels. Additional specialized integrations or advanced API functionalities may incur extra costs. The platform offers straightforward connectivity options but may require supplemental investments for extensive customization or complex integrations.

SecurityScoreCard offers an extensive marketplace of integrations with security, GRC, and workflow platforms. However, integrations tend to primarily focus on score visibility in other platforms rather than workflow extensibility. Offers integrations with several third-party platforms, such as RSA Archer, ServiceNow, and more.

Purchasing & licensing transparency

UpGuard publishes its pricing rather than hiding it behind a sales call. A free tier lets teams monitor up to five vendors and use Trust Exchange, UpGuard’s AI-powered questionnaire tool, at no cost. Paid Vendor Risk plans start at USD 1,750 per month, billed annually. Teams can start with one product and add others as they scale. One license covers both monitoring and assessments, so pricing doesn’t fragment across separate products.

Panorays offers a free plan for assessing up to five vendors and a full-featured free trial. However, detailed public pricing information is not disclosed, and users must contact sales directly for tailored quotes. Panorays features a complex pricing structure involving multiple service tiers (Continuous 360° Evaluation, Bi-Annual 360° Evaluation, Continuous Posture Evaluation, Bi-Annual Posture Evaluation, Smart Questionnaires), potentially complicating purchasing decisions and budget forecasting

Public pricing information is not available. Offers a free plan and a 14-day free trial for paid plans.

Customers

UpGuard customers include Intercontinental Exchange (NYSE: ICE), Morningstar, TDK, PagerDuty, Hopin, and IAG. Read UpGuard’s customer stories to learn more.

Major customers include Avis, Arvest, Quantum, and Payoneer.

Major customers include Hershey, Cleveland Clinic, Avangrid, and ADT.

G2 rating Accurate as of March 2025

More than 700 verified reviews give UpGuard a 4.5 out of 5 rating on G2. UpGuard also holds G2’s top ranking as the leader in Third-Party & Supplier Risk Management for 15 consecutive quarters. The 2026 G2 Best Software Awards recognized UpGuard as one of the Top 100 Global Software Companies. Among verified reviewers, 98% give UpGuard four- or five-star ratings, and 94% approve of its product direction.

4.3, based on 35 reviews.

4.2, based on 75 reviews.

Security ratings

943 / 950

833 / 950

802 / 950

Panorays vs SecurityScorecard product overview

Learn more about the products and how they compare.

As outsourcing significant business functions is now common practice for most organizations, major third-party data breaches are rapidly taking over news headlines.

Ponemon Institute and IBM’s Cost of a Data Breach Report found the average cost of a breach has increased from $370,000 to $4.35 million, with third-party involvement listed as one of the main reasons. An eSentire survey from the same year highlights that 44% of firms surveyed have experienced a significant data breach caused by a third-party vendor.

With Gartner reporting 60% of organizations as having 1000+ third-party relationships, effectively managing the cybersecurity risks they create and practicing vendor due diligence proves increasingly difficult.

Information security teams often also rely on manual risk reporting methods which are time and labor-intensive. Many organizations are now turning to automated third-party risk management (TPRM) solutions that automate data breach detection capabilities, provide real-time insights, and streamline remediation workflows.

We assess three TPRM solutions, Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard, to help you make an informed decision before investing in the right solution for your needs.

Panorays Overview

Panorays is a US incorporated company operating largely in Tel Aviv, Israel. The Panorays platform helps users discover, assess, and monitor their cybersecurity risk exposure from third-party vendors in their digital supply chain.

The Panorays platform leverages third-party security ratings, security questionnaires, and remediation workflows to help customers reduce risk through improved due diligence across vendor relationships, mergers & acquisitions, and executive visibility.

Panorays' UI. Source: G2.com

Panorays’ UI. Source: G2.com

SecurityScorecard Overview

SecurityScorecard is a New York-based security ratings platform that uses traffic and other publicly accessible data to build security ratings to evaluate vendors and manage cyber risk among other use cases.

SecurityScoreCard also monitors “hacker chatter” and other public data feeds for indicators of compromise.

SecurityScorecard's UI

SecurityScorecard’s UI. Source: securityscorecard.com.

UpGuard Overview

UpGuard is a third-party risk and attack surface management platform that helps global organizations prevent data breaches, monitor third-party vendors, and improve their security posture. UpGuard’s platform uses proprietary security ratings, data leak detection capabilities, and remediation workflows to proactively identify security exposures. UpGuard’s all-in-one third-party risk and attack surface management software intelligently groups risks into six categories: website risks, email security, network security, phishing & malware, reputation risk, and brand protection.

Usability and the learning curve

Minimizing the amount of time and effort in learning to use a new solution is a critical aspect of delivering on any value proposition.

Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard offer their services via SaaS and are accessible from web-based platforms that can help users monitor and manage vendor risks.

Panorays: A fully cloud-based service with minimal installation criteria required. The easy-to-use navigation interface and reporting functionality is also well regarded.

SecurityScorecard: Simple interface for quick grade reports and charts.

UpGuard: Clean interface offers intuitive navigation to precise risk insights, workflow management, and reporting. Cloud-based platform provides turnkey deployment with no installation required.

Capabilities

Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard help organizations stay informed about their vendors’ information security risks as part of a third-party risk management (TPRM) program.

Panorays: Helps organizations automate their third-party risk assessment and vendor compliance due diligence processes.

SecurityScorecard: Provides security ratings that aggregate different risks into a single score, allowing for the comparison of different third-party vendors and service providers.

UpGuard: Offers real-time visibility into any third-party vendor’s risk posture & security rating along with total automation for managing vendor due diligence and remediation programs.

A significant point of difference between SecurityScorecard and UpGuard is the amount of time required to perform a non-intrusive scan.

SecurityScorecard takes 10 days to perform a non-intrusive scan across the entire IPv4 web space, whereas UpGuard’s scan is completed in just 24 hours. Shorter scanning times mean open ports and misconfigured services have less chance of being exploited by cybercriminals, Smaller scan frequencies help you discover critical data breach risks, like open ports, faster.

Community support

Keeping informed on product updates and the latest cyber security developments is paramount, with new vulnerabilities and cyber threats emerging daily.

Customers need up-to-date resources and relevant insights to stay ahead of the curve and protect their organizations from emerging cyber risks.

The frequency of publication and presence of community engagement is a key indicator of a company’s mission, focus, and investment in its users.

Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard offer comprehensive online resources to educate and inform customers.

Panorays: Panorays engages their user community with regular blog posts on topics covering relevant security incidents, new feature updates, and industry developments.

Panorays also offers live and recorded webinars to help viewers align their programs to best security practices.

SecurityScorecard: SecurityScoreCard offers a user Academy for customer users along with a regularly updated company blog, webinar series, and resource center.

UpGuard: UpGuard Summit brings together a community of security leaders from leading companies, explores the future of security, and helps businesses stay secure.

The UpGuard cybersecurity and risk management blog is updated four times a week and the breach research blog has uncovered and secured some of the largest data breaches.

UpGuard’s free weekly Breach Newsletter informs 20,000+ subscribers of the latest global data breaches.

Release rate

Technology is always changing. New vulnerabilities are added to CVE on a daily basis, and attackers are constantly finding new zero-day exploits.

The speed at which a security platform can incorporate changes determines how well it can respond to new threats and customer requests.

Additionally, they should continue to update, adjust, and improve their threat detection methodology to reflect changes to the threat landscape.

Panorays: Panorays’ support pages do not currently appear to document release notes about changes to the platform’s functionalities.

SecurityScorecard: SecurityScoreCard makes releases as needed throughout the year, consistently enabling customer users to access information logs of beneficial changes.

UpGuard: UpGuard has adopted DevOps principles internally to develop, test, and release software continuously, ensuring fast, consistent, and safe releases.

UpGuard has a regular release rate every two weeks, with all features, changes, and improvements listed under UpGuard Release Notes.

Pricing and support

Cyber risk platforms can be expensive and the common use of opaque pricing policies often takes power away from the purchaser. With most services offering tiered licensing options and add-ons, finding a solution that fits your needs and budget can prove more difficult without transparent pricing.

Panorays: Public-facing pricing is not available. Prospective customers must engage with a Panorays representative to receive pricing quotes for different subscription tiers, with higher tiers allowing for a greater number of monitored vendors and customer users. View esimates of Panoray’s pricing.

SecurityScorecard: Public pricing information is not available. Reports say pricing SecurityScorecar’d platform starts at $16,500 for self-assessment plus five vendors, and additional vendors cost $1,500-$2,000 per vendor per year.

UpGuard: UpGuard has a fully transparent and publicly accessible pricing model which you can view here. If you have any questions, please email sales@upguard.com.

API and extensibility

Accessing the information in a cyber risk product outside of its graphical interface is important for integrated business strategies and consolidating data to a preferred system.

Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard offer APIs.

Panorays: Offers a JSON-based REST API, that customers can use to build the connections needed to transmit Panorays elements into third-party applications.

SecurityScorecard: SecurityScoreCard offers API connections for users seeking greater security ratings extensibility.

UpGuard: Offers a standard API to pull data from UpGuard’s platform into other enterprise applications.

Third-party integrations

APIs are useful for technical staff, but not all information security teams have access to developers. In this situation, standard third-party integrations are an essential part of decision-making.

Panorays, SecurityScorecard, and UpGuard offer integrations into other platforms.

Panorays: Offers out-of-the-box integrations with a limited number of third-party platforms, such as ServiceNow and RSA Archer.

However, most alerting connections to third-party platforms will require development support for custom integrations available via the standard webhook connector available in the platform.

SecurityScorecard: Offers integrations with several third party platforms, such as RSA Archer, ServiceNow, and more.

UpGuard:Integrates with Zapier to enable connections to 3,000+ apps; GRC platforms, ticketing systems like JIRA; VRM solutions like ServiceNow, and more.

Customers

Panorays: Features most of their customers as belonging in the mid-market segment, such as Mixpanel, WalkMe, and Zerto.

SecurityScorecard: Major customers include Hershey, Cleveland Clinic, Avangrid, and ADT.

UpGuard: Major customers across highly regulated sectors include Accenture, New York Stock Exchange, Tech Mahindra, and Morningstar.

Security rating

Panorays: Security rating scale of 0-100, ranked as Bad, Poor, Fair, Good, or Excellent. Security rating scores are a weighted average of the risk rating of all externally facing assets and completed vendor questionnaire scores.

SecurityScorecard: Provides a security rating on a numerical scale from 0-100 with letter scale breakdowns ranged within an A - F report card based scale.

UpGuard: Security rating scale of 0-950, ranked as A: 801-950, B: 601-800, C: 401-600, D: 201-400, F: 0-200. You can request your free security rating by clicking here.

Panorays vs SecurityScorecard

Did you know UpGuard was voted #1 on G2 and has been for over two years?